Which is better for your money? ISA vs. savings account

POSTED ON Wednesday, 15 May, 2024

Managing your money through saving and investing is key to building a secure financial future. Whether it’s planning for a big purchase, your retirement, or simply looking to grow your wealth, choosing the right ISA or savings account is essential.

You might wonder, “Should I open an ISA or stick with an ordinary savings account?”

This decision can be confusing, especially with so many options and terms to consider.

In this article, we’ll explain the differences between Individual Savings Accounts (ISAs) and traditional savings accounts, exploring how each works, its benefits, and its drawbacks. We aim to help you understand which option might be best for your money.

By the end of this read, you’ll have a clearer picture of where to put your savings to achieve your financial goals. Let’s dive in and find the best savings options for your hard-earned money.

What is an ISA?

An Individual Savings Account (ISA) allows you to save or invest your money without paying tax on the interest, dividends, or capital gains you earn. ISAs are designed to encourage saving by offering tax advantages, making them a smart choice if you’re looking to grow your wealth efficiently.

Find out more: What is an ISA

Definition and types

ISAs come in several types, each catering to different savings and investment preferences. Here’s a breakdown of the main types of ISAs available:

Cash ISAs

Cash ISAs work like regular savings accounts but with the benefit of tax-free interest. If you want a low-risk way to save, a Cash ISA is a good option. You can choose between:

Investment ISAs

Investment ISAs (also known as a Stocks and Shares ISA) let you invest in stocks, bonds, and mutual funds. The returns on these investments are tax-free, which can lead to higher growth than a Cash ISA. However, investments can go up or down in value, so a higher risk is involved. If you’re comfortable with this risk and seeking potentially higher returns, an Investment ISA might be for you.

Innovative Finance ISAs

Innovative Finance ISAs (IFISAs) allow you to lend your money to individuals or businesses through peer-to-peer lending platforms. The interest you earn is tax-free.

IFISAs can offer higher returns than Cash ISAs, but they carry higher risk since borrowers might default on their loans. If you’re looking for higher returns and are willing to accept the risk, consider an IFISA.

Junior ISAs

Junior ISAs are designed for children under 18. You can open these accounts as a parent or guardian and save or invest on behalf of your child. Grandparents and other family members can also contribute to the account, but can’t operate it or control where the funds are invested. The money is locked away until your child turns 18, at which point it converts into an adult ISA in their name.

Junior ISAs can be either Cash ISAs or Investment ISAs, providing flexible saving or investing options with the benefit of tax-free growth. A Junior ISA is a great choice if you want to start saving early for your child’s future.

Tax benefits of ISAs

The big advantage of an ISA is the tax-free savings. When you save or invest through an ISA, you don’t have to pay any tax on the interest, dividends, or capital gains you earn. This means all the money your ISA makes stays with you, unlike regular savings or investment accounts where a portion of your earnings could go to taxes.

Here’s how ISAs can help you maximise your savings:

  1. No income tax on interest: In a regular savings account, the interest is subject to income tax if it exceeds your personal savings allowance. With a Cash ISA, you don’t pay income tax on the interest, helping your savings to grow faster.
  2. No Capital Gains Tax: When you sell investments at a profit in a regular investment account, you might have to pay capital gains tax if your gains exceed the annual exemption limit. Investment ISAs shield you from this tax, so all your gains stay in your pocket.
  3. No dividend tax: Dividends from stocks and shares are usually taxed if they exceed your dividend allowance. Again, these dividends are tax-free within an Investment ISA, letting you keep more of your earnings.

What is a savings account?

A traditional savings account is a basic banking tool that allows you to deposit money and earn interest over time. Savings accounts are designed to help you grow your money while keeping it easily accessible. They are safe, straightforward, and ideal for short-term savings goals or emergency funds.

Definition and types

There are several types of savings accounts, each catering to different needs and preferences. Here’s a quick overview:

Regular savings accounts

Easy-access savings accounts are the most common type. They offer a simple way to save money and earn interest. These ordinary savings accounts are simple to open and maintain and have no long-term commitments. You can deposit and withdraw money whenever you want, making them perfect for day-to-day savings. However, the interest rates are usually lower compared to other savings options.

Notice accounts

Notice savings accounts provide better interest rates than easy-access savings accounts, but as the name suggests, they require you to give notice when you want to access your cash rather than instantly access it.

They are designed to reward you for saving more. These accounts might require a higher minimum balance or limit the number of withdrawals you can make each month. They could be a good choice if you have a substantial amount to save and want to earn more interest.

Fixed-term savings accounts

Fixed-rate savings accounts lock your money away for a set period, ranging from a few months to several years. In return, you receive a fixed interest rate that is often higher than regular or high-interest savings accounts. These accounts are ideal if you don’t need immediate access to your money and want a guaranteed return on your savings. However, withdrawing money before the term ends can result in penalties or loss of interest.

Interest rates and tax implications

Interest rates determine how much your money will grow in a savings account.

Here’s a quick look at how they work:

  1. Variable interest rates: Many savings accounts offer variable interest rates, which can change over time based on market conditions and the bank’s policies. Your earnings may increase or decrease depending on these fluctuations.
  2. Fixed interest rates: Some accounts, especially fixed-term savings accounts, offer fixed interest rates. This means the rate is set for a specific period, providing predictable returns. Fixed rates are usually higher than variable rates, but you can’t benefit from potential rate increases during the term.
  3. Compound interest: Savings accounts typically use compound interest, where the interest you earn is added to your principal balance, and you earn interest on the new total in the next period. This can significantly boost your savings over time.

Tax implications for savings account interest earnings

Interest earned on savings accounts is considered taxable income. 

Here’s what you need to know:

  1. Personal Savings Allowance: In the UK, you have a Personal Savings Allowance that lets you earn a certain amount of interest tax-free each year. Basic rate taxpayers can earn up to £1,000 tax-free, while higher rate taxpayers can earn up to £500. Additional rate taxpayers do not receive this allowance.
  2. Tax rates: If your interest earnings exceed your Personal Savings Allowance, you must pay tax on the excess. This tax is charged at your usual income tax rate—20% for basic rate taxpayers, 40% for higher rate taxpayers, and 45% for additional rate taxpayers.
  3. Automatic tax deduction: Sometimes, banks automatically deduct tax from your interest before paying it to you. However, most banks no longer do this, and you’ll need to report any taxable interest on your annual tax return.

Comparison: ISA vs. savings account

Understanding the key differences between ISAs and traditional savings accounts can help you choose the best option for your financial goals:

Accessibility and flexibility

ISAs restrict the amount you can deposit each year and the time you can withdraw funds without penalties. Traditional savings accounts generally offer more flexibility, allowing you to access your money anytime without penalties, making them ideal for emergency funds.

Interest rates and returns

ISAs can offer higher potential returns, especially with Investment ISAs, but the returns depend on market performance. Traditional savings accounts typically provide lower, more stable interest rates. In times of high market performance, ISAs might yield better returns, while savings accounts offer more secure growth.

Risk and security

Traditional savings accounts are low-risk, making them safe places to keep money. Investment ISAs carry higher risks, as their value can fluctuate with market conditions. However, cash ISAs are low-risk and similar to savings accounts. Both account types are protected up to certain limits by financial compensation schemes.

Fees and charges

ISAs, especially investment ISAs, may have management fees or transaction charges that can impact your returns. Traditional savings accounts usually have fewer or no fees, making them a cost-effective option for straightforward saving.

It’s important to consider these costs when calculating potential returns from ISAs.

When to choose an ISA

An ISA is a fantastic option if you want to grow your money, save or invest it, and enjoy tax benefits. ISAs are perfect for long-term savers and investors looking to maximise returns without worrying about tax liabilities.

  • Cash ISAs are great if you want a safe, low-risk place to save with easy access to your money.
  • Investment ISAs are ideal for those ready to take on some risk for potentially higher returns through stocks, bonds, and mutual funds.
  • Innovative Finance ISAs are perfect if you want to lend your money through peer-to-peer platforms for higher yields.
  • Junior ISAs are excellent for parents who want to start a tax-free savings journey for their child’s future.

When to choose a savings account

A traditional savings account is often better if you need easy access to your funds or are saving for short-term goals. These accounts are excellent for building an emergency fund or setting aside money for an upcoming expense, like a holiday or home improvement project.

Fixed-rate savings accounts are great if you can set aside your money for a specific period to earn higher interest rates. These accounts provide a safe, predictable return on your savings.

Take control of your savings today!

Ready to make the most of your money? Whether you choose an ISA or a traditional savings account, the key is to start now.

Determine your financial goals, consider your risk tolerance, and pick the best savings option that suits your needs.

Don’t wait—begin your journey to financial freedom today.

Contact us today. Start saving now and secure your future.